An analysis of predatory insects in farmlands in China based on the CNKI database: Future potential and current application

doi:10.7679/j.issn.2095-1353.2020.01.008

Abstract

Abstract:

[Objectives] To determine the future potential and current application of predatory insects as biological control agents in Chinese farmland. [Methods] Chinese literature on the potential, and current, use of predatory insects in farmland for biological control collected by the CNKI database was identified and analyzed using the bibliometrics method. [Results] 544 predatory insect-related papers and 1 747 relevant key words were identified. The identified contents were mainly on the arthropod community and the dominant predatory species in farmland, key predators in farmland; predation, food webs, evaluating the value of the ecological services provided by predators, artificial breeding, artificial feeding, the release and application of predators, key pests of major crops and integrated pest management. Most papers were on the rice and cotton ecosystem and its associated pests and their natural enemies. Harmonia axyridis, Coccinella septempunctata, Propylea japonica, Cyrtorhinus lividipennis, Paederus fuscipe, Micraspis discolor and Microvelia horvathi are the dominant predatory insects in Chinese farmland. [Conclusion] There is great potential for utilizing predatory insects for biological control in the main farmland ecosystems in China. More research on the occurrence of important pest populations is required, as is research on the conditions preferred by these species and their biocontrol efficiency.

Key words: farmland, predatory insect, predatory lady beetle, ecological service, CNKI database

Yu-Fang LIU, Wen-Hua ZHAO, Fei YANG, Mei-Qi XIE, Si-Yuan CHEN. An analysis of predatory insects in farmlands in China based on the CNKI database: Future potential and current application[J]. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 2020, 57(1): 70-79.

Figures/Tables 6

References 36

[1]	Cai ZP, Ouyang F, Ge F, Zhang JP , 2019. Quantitative evaluation of the biological control efficiency of predatory insects based on rubidium marking method. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 56(2):348-353.
	[ 蔡志平, 肖云丽, 欧阳芳, 戈峰, 张建平 , 2019. 定量评价天敌昆虫控害功能的铷元素标记技术. 应用昆虫学报, 56(2):348-353.]
[2]	Chen CM, Song HY, Xiao TG , 1980. Insect resources of natural enemy in rice field in Hunan province. Journal of Hunan Agricultural College, ( 1):35-46.
	[ 陈常铭, 宋慧英, 肖铁光 , 1980. 湖南稻田天敌昆虫资源. 湖南农学院学报, ( 1):35-46.]
[3]	Chen XX, Liu YQ, Ren SX, Zhang F, Zhang WQ, Ge F , 2014. Plant-mediated support system for natural enemies of insect pests. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 51(1):1-12.
	[ 陈学新, 刘银泉, 任顺祥, 张帆, 张文庆, 戈峰 , 2014. 害虫天敌的植物支持系统. 应用昆虫学报, 51(1):1-12.]
[4]	Ge F, Ding YQ , 1996. The population energy dynamics of predacious natural enemies and their pest control activity in different cotton agroecosystems. Acta Entomologica Sinica, 39(3):266-273.
	[ 戈峰, 丁岩钦 , 1996. 不同类型棉田捕食性天敌的种群能量动态及其对害虫的控制作用. 昆虫学报, 39(3):266-273.]
[5]	Ge F, Liu XF, Pang WD, Ding YQ , 2002. Biological control efficiency of ladybirds on arthropod pests in cotton agroecosystems. Chinese Journal of Applied Ecology, 13(7):841-844. URL pmid: 12385215
	[ 戈峰, 刘向辉, 潘卫东, 丁岩钦 , 2002. 棉田捕食性瓢虫控害功能的分析. 应用生态学报, 13(7):841-844.] pmid: 12385215
[6]	Ge F, Ouyang F , 2014. Quantitative evaluation of the biological control value of predatory insects based on ecological energetic analyses. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 51(1):307-313.
	[ 戈峰, 欧阳芳 , 2014. 定量评价天敌控害功能的生态能学方法. 应用昆虫学报, 51(1):307-313.]
[7]	Jiang JG, Zhang ZQ, Yu X, Ma DC, Yu CH Liu F, Mu W , 2018. Influence of lethal and sublethal exposure to clothianidin on the sevenspotted lady beetle, Coccinella septempunctata L. (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae). Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 161:208-213. doi: 10.1016/j.ecoenv.2018.05.076 URL
[8]	Khan MM, Nawaz M, Hua HX, Cai WL, Zhao J , 2018. Lethal and sublethal effects of emamectin benzoate on the rove beetle, Paederus fuscipes, a non-target predator of rice brown planthopper, Nilaparvata lugens. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 165:19-24.
[9]	Li J, Jin CZ, Long DB, Ouyang F, Ge F , 2014. Non-lethal effects of a natural enemy on herbivore insect population. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 51(4):863-870.
	[ 李姣, 金晨钟, 龙大彬, 欧阳芳, 戈峰 , 2014. 天敌昆虫对害虫的非直接致死效应. 应用昆虫学报, 51(4):863-870.]
[10]	Liu FJ, Zeng FR , 2013. Advances in artificial diet for rearing of predatory bugs. Chinese Journal of Biological Control, 29(2):294-300.
	[ 刘丰姣, 曾凡荣 , 2013. 捕食性蝽类昆虫人工饲料研究进展. 中国生物防治学报, 29(2):294-300.]
[11]	Liu YF , 2016. Bibliometric review of international research on insect-resistant transgenic Bt rice. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 53(3):648-659.
	[ 刘雨芳 , 2016. 基于WOS文献计量的转Bt基因抗虫水稻研究国际动态分析. 应用昆虫学报, 53(3):648-659.]
[12]	Liu YF , 2017. A bibliometric analysis of Chinese entomology based on WOS and CSCD between 2011 and 2016. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 54(6):898-908.
	[ 刘雨芳 , 2017. 基于WOS与CSCD文献计量的中国昆虫学研究透视(2011-2016). 应用昆虫学报, 54(6):898-908.]
[13]	Liu YF , 2019. A review of the diversity and ecological function of paddy field insect communities in China. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 56(2):183-194.
	[ 刘雨芳 , 2019. 中国稻田昆虫群落多样性及生态调控功能研究进展. 应用昆虫学报, 56(2):183-194.]
[14]	Liu YF, Sun LC, Jiang YL . 2017. Bibliometric review of research on phytoplankton in water quality assessment. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 37(3):165-172.
[15]	Liu YF, Yang H, Yang F, Xie MQ , 2019a. Analysis of research on the relationship between habitat heterogeneity and biodiversity in worldwide. Insect Research of Central China, 15:260-268.
	[ 刘雨芳, 杨荷, 阳菲, 谢美琦 , 2019 a. 生境异质性与生物多样性关系研究态势分析. 华中昆虫研究, 15:260-268.]
[16]	Liu YF, Yang H, Yang F, Xie MQ , 2019 b. Ecological regulation effectiveness of habitat heterogeneity on predatory natural enemies and rice pests in rice paddy fields. Acta Entomologica Sinica, 62(7):857-867.
	[ 刘雨芳, 杨荷, 阳菲, 谢美琦 , 2019b. 生境异质度对稻田捕食性天敌及水稻害虫的生态调节有效性. 昆虫学报, 62(7):857-867.]
[17]	Liu YF, Zhang GR, Gu DX, Wen RZ , 2002. Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay used to detect the food relationships of the arthropods in paddy fields. Acta Entomologica Sinica, 45(3):352-358.
	[ 刘雨芳, 张古忍, 古德祥, 温瑞贞 , 2002. 用ELISA方法研究稻田节肢动物的食物关系. 昆虫学报, 45(3):352-358.]
[18]	Liu YQ, Shi ZH, Zalucki MP, Liu SS , 2014. Conservation biological control and IPM practices in Brassica vegetable crops in China. Biological Control, 68:37-46.
[19]	Luo XC, Li JR , 1965. Research of artificial release of lady beetle, Harmonia axyridis to control aphids on cucumber. Entomological Knowledge, 9(2):99.
	[ 罗希成, 李井茹 , 1965. 人工释放异色瓢虫防治黄瓜蚜虫的初步研究. 昆虫知识, 9(2):99.]
[20]	Ouyang F, Cao J, Ge F , 2014. Quantitative evaluation of the biological control efficiency of predatory insects based on stable isotope analyses. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 51(1):302-306.
	[ 欧阳芳, 曹婧, 戈峰 , 2014. 定量评价天敌昆虫控害功能的稳定同位素方法. 应用昆虫学报, 51(1):302-306.]
[21]	Ouyang F, Lü F, Men XY, Zhao ZH, Zeng JP, Xiao YL, Ge F , 2015. The economic value of ecological regulating services provided by agricultural insects in China. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 35(12):4000-4006.
	[ 欧阳芳, 吕飞, 门兴元, 赵紫华, 曾菊平, 肖云丽, 戈峰 , 2015. 中国农业昆虫生态调节服务价值估算. 生态学报, 35(12):4000-4006.]
[22]	Rajendran TP, Singh D , 2016. Insects and Pests//Omkar(ed.). Ecofriendly Pest Management for Food Security. Elsevier: Academic Press. 1-24.
[23]	Sun MM, Cai WG, Chen JH, Wang LL , 2015. The control effect of aphids on cabbage by artificial release lady beetle, Harmonia axyridis. Zhejiang Agricultural Science, 56(9):1452-1453, 1456.
	[ 孙梅梅, 柴伟纲, 谌江华, 王丽丽 , 2015. 人工释放异色瓢虫对甘蓝蚜的控制效果. 浙江农业科学, 56(9):1452-1453, 1456.]
[24]	Wang HT, Zhang WD, Chen XZ, Zheng JF, Miao L, Qin QL , 2012. Mass rearing the multicolored Asian lady beetle on beet armyworm larvae. Chinese Journal of Applied Entomology, 49(6):1726-1731.
	[ 王红托, 张伟东, 陈新中, 郑建峰, 苗麟, 秦启联 , 2012. 异色瓢虫规模化生产技术及瓢虫工厂的建立. 应用昆虫学报, 49(6):1726-1731.]
[25]	Xiao TG, Tang JX , 2007. Effects of the susceptibility of rice varieties to Sogatella furcifera on nymphal development and reproduction of Microvelia horvathi through a food chain. Insect Science, 14(4):317-321.
[26]	Xu HX, Zheng XS, Tian JC, Lai FX, He JC, Lü ZX , 2017. Advances in the development and application of control technologies for insect pest management in paddy fields in China. Journal of Plant Protection, 44(6):925-939.
	[ 徐红星, 郑许松, 田俊策, 赖凤香, 何佳春, 吕仲贤 , 2017. 我国水稻害虫绿色防控技术的研究进展与应用现状. 植物保护学报, 44(6):925-939.]
[27]	Yang L, Xu L, Liu B, Zhang Q, Pan YF, Li Q, Li HQ, Lu YH , 2019. Non-crop habitats promote the abundance of predatory ladybeetles in maize fields in the agricultural landscape of northern China. Agriculture, Ecosystems and Environment, 277:44-52.
[28]	Yang Y , 2018. Establishment and trial application of a database of arthropods in Chinese main crops fields. Doctoral dissertation. Beijing: Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences.
	[ 杨艳 , 2018. 中国主要作物田节肢动物数据库的构建与试用. 博士学位论文. 北京: 中国农业科学院.]
[29]	Yang YJ, Liu K, Han HL, Xu HX, Zhang FC, Zheng XS, Tian J, Wang GY, Chen GH, Lu ZX , 2016. Impacts of nitrogen fertilizer on major insect pests and their predators in transgenic Bt rice lines T2A-1 and T1C-19. Entomologia Experimentalis et Applicata, 160(3):281-291.
[30]	Zhang J, Zheng X, Jian H, Qin X, Yuan F, Zhang R , 2013. Arthropod biodiversity and community structures of organic rice ecosystems in Guangdong province, China. Florida Entomologist, 96(1):1-9.
[31]	Zhang LL, Li K, Zhang TS, Wang B , 2007. The effect of the artificial diets on Propylea japonica growth and fecundity. Chinese Bulletin of Entomology, 44(6):871-876.
	[ 张丽丽, 李恺, 张天澍, 王斌 , 2007. 人工饲料对龟纹瓢虫生长和繁殖的影响. 昆虫知识, 44(6):871-876.]
[32]	Zhang S, Mao JJ, Zeng FR , 2015. Effects of an artificial diet with non-insect ingredient on biological characteristics of Harmonia axyridis (Pallas). Chinese Journal of Biological Control, 31(1):35-40.
	[ 张屾, 毛建军, 曾凡荣 , 2015. 非昆虫源人工饲料对异色瓢虫生物学特性的影响. 中国生物防治学报, 31(1):35-40.]
[33]	Zhang YS, Ouyang F, Men XY, Ge F, Yuan ZM , 2018. Effects of regional agricultural landscape patterns on populations of wheat aphids. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 38(23):8652-8659.
	[ 张永生, 欧阳芳, 门兴元, 戈峰, 袁哲明 , 2018. 区域农田景观格局对麦蚜种群数量的影响. 生态学报, 38(23):8652-8659.]
[34]	Zhou XM , 2008. Key technology of mass rearing of Orius similis and its ecological basement of field release. Doctoral dissertation. Wuhan: Huazhong Agricultural University.
	[ 周兴苗 , 2008. 南方小花蝽大量繁殖关键技术及其田间释放生态学基础研究. 武汉: 华中农业大学.]
[35]	Zhou YH, Cheng Y, Jin JX, Li WH, Li FL , 2017. Large scale production and release application of Coccinella septempunctata. Southwest China Journal of Agricultural Sciences, 30(3):602-605.
	[ 周宇航, 程英, 金剑雪, 李文红, 李凤良 , 2017. 七星瓢虫规模化生产与释放的应用效果. 西南农业学报, 30(3):602-605.]
[36]	Zhu DL , 2016. Studies on artificial rearing and taxis reaction to volatile phytochemicals of Harpactor fuscipes (Fabrieius). Maste dissertation. Guangzhou: South China Agricultural University.
	[ 朱丹荔 , 2016. 红彩真猎蝽的人工饲养和其对信息化合物的趋性反应研究. 广州: 华南农业大学.]

主题词 Key word	总计 Total	文献类别 Literature category				最早收藏文献日期 Date of the earliest document collected	重要词量 Number of key word
主题词 Key word	总计 Total	期刊论文 Journal article	硕士论文 Master thesis	博士论文 Doctor thesis	会议论文Conference proceedings	最早收藏文献日期 Date of the earliest document collected	重要词量 Number of key word
捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect	491	202	181	95	13	1958-7-30	1 572
捕食性瓢虫 Predatory lady beetle	43	37	2	2	2	1979-12-31	174
农业捕食性昆虫 Agricultural predatory insect	93	11	52	30	0	1982-5-1	376
稻田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in rice field	61	17	23	20	1	1985-3-2	281
棉田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in cotton field	34	6	19	9	0	2002-7-30	122
农田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in farmland	17	4	10	3	0	1981-6-30	78
玉米田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in corn field	18	4	10	4	0	2003-6-1	68
麦田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in wheat field	10	2	5	3	0	2007-4-1	51
果园捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in orchard	17	3	10	4	0	1958-07-30	75

主题词 Key word	总计 Total	文献类别 Literature category				最早收藏文献日期 Date of the earliest document collected	重要词量 Number of key word
主题词 Key word	总计 Total	期刊论文 Journal article	硕士论文 Master thesis	博士论文 Doctor thesis	会议论文Conference proceedings	最早收藏文献日期 Date of the earliest document collected	重要词量 Number of key word
捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect	491	202	181	95	13	1958-7-30	1 572
捕食性瓢虫 Predatory lady beetle	43	37	2	2	2	1979-12-31	174
农业捕食性昆虫 Agricultural predatory insect	93	11	52	30	0	1982-5-1	376
稻田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in rice field	61	17	23	20	1	1985-3-2	281
棉田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in cotton field	34	6	19	9	0	2002-7-30	122
农田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in farmland	17	4	10	3	0	1981-6-30	78
玉米田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in corn field	18	4	10	4	0	2003-6-1	68
麦田捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in wheat field	10	2	5	3	0	2007-4-1	51
果园捕食性昆虫 Predatory insect in orchard	17	3	10	4	0	1958-07-30	75

重要物种 Key species	总计 Total	文献类别Literature category				最早收藏文献日期 Date of the earliest document collected
重要物种 Key species	总计 Total	期刊论文 Journal article	硕士论文 Master thesis	博士论文 Doctor thesis	会议论文Conference proceedings	最早收藏文献日期 Date of the earliest document collected
异色瓢虫Harmonia axyridis	665	537	83	9	36	1960-05-30
七星瓢虫Coccinella septempunctata	455	391	24	4	36	1962-11-15
龟纹瓢虫Propylea japonica	366	285	54	7	20	1976-02-08
黑肩绿盲蝽Cyrtorhinus lividipennis	142	110	16	7	9	1977-05-01
青翅蚁形隐翅虫Paederus fuscipes	50	48	1	0	1	1981-03-02
稻红瓢虫Micraspis discolor	19	17	1	0	1	1959-04-01
尖钩宽黾蝽Microvelia horvathi	15	13	1	1	0	1987-06-30

重要物种 Key species	总计 Total	文献类别Literature category				最早收藏文献日期 Date of the earliest document collected
重要物种 Key species	总计 Total	期刊论文 Journal article	硕士论文 Master thesis	博士论文 Doctor thesis	会议论文Conference proceedings	最早收藏文献日期 Date of the earliest document collected
异色瓢虫Harmonia axyridis	665	537	83	9	36	1960-05-30
七星瓢虫Coccinella septempunctata	455	391	24	4	36	1962-11-15
龟纹瓢虫Propylea japonica	366	285	54	7	20	1976-02-08
黑肩绿盲蝽Cyrtorhinus lividipennis	142	110	16	7	9	1977-05-01
青翅蚁形隐翅虫Paederus fuscipes	50	48	1	0	1	1981-03-02
稻红瓢虫Micraspis discolor	19	17	1	0	1	1959-04-01
尖钩宽黾蝽Microvelia horvathi	15	13	1	1	0	1987-06-30